Just wondering if anyone has had any experience renting a car in St. Thomas and if its a quick and easy process or a long one? We get in 11am tomorrow and rather then take a taxi to the marina and then again to shopping for provisions I was thinking it might be more convenient to rent a car for the day. Probably rent on arrival and return later in the day. Cost looks like it will be a little more then just using a taxi for all our needs but at the same time it gives us flexibility to explore as well.

But if the rental and return process is a mess there and takes a while I'm thinking it may not be worth it? I'm a hertz gold member and have always had good luck with things moving quickly, just not sure if that applies in STT?

Thanks!