My experience with DYC at Scrub was great. Also had no issues with the boat, a Lagoon 450, which makes most of the difference. Scrub does have good amenities - we didn't do too much exploring of the island, but make sure you save some time for the pool. Can't beat the view and setting. There's also a small store that might help with some forgotten provisioning items.

My last 2 trips with DYC were to the Spanish Virgin Islands and Key West. We had to deal with some material boat issues. My perception now is that they don't maintain their fleet very well.

I'll won't book with them in the future if I can avoid it. I believe they've actually closed the Puerto Rico base since we went last November.