I'm sorry, I haven't heard of this agency, though did a quick internet search, of course. They are ATOL protected, which is a type of acceptance by the UK government and means the business is secure. If they suddenly went out of business, for example, after I had booked a holiday, it would be covered. Not sure how that would translate across to US citizens. They certainly seem to have lots of islands on their website. I would find it hard to choose..... We went around about 2000 I think and can't remember how we chose our island. From our experience you might want to seriously consider the All Inclusive option as there wont be many, if any, dining options. It truly is one island=one hotel: nothing else. Also, we arrived at our hotel via a sea plane, which could be off-putting to some. It was a completely new experience for us which turned out to be a fantastic mode of travel and the take offs and landings were probably some of the smoothest I have ever encountered )and we fly a lot). Fabulous views goes without saying. I am feeling a little envious. I would love to return but my husband is not a swimmer or snorkeler and was bored after a couple of days. I wasn't!!