Well, since Nisbet closed, we decided that maybe we should try a new island. We have visited about a dozen Caribbean and Pacific islands so far. In the Caribbean, we’ve been to all of the BVIs, St. John, Exuma, Long Island, Jamaica, Anguilla, St. Martin, Grenada, St. Kitts, and Nevis. Our favorite (and the only island we’ve returned to) is Nevis. We have enjoyed most of the islands we've visited (Jamaica was not my favorite) but Nevis won our hearts. So, is there another island like Nevis that is not on our previous island list? Good to great restaurants, not too crowded, no need for “nightlife”, smaller resorts and not egregiously expensive (e.g., Montpelier, Biras Creek (RIP), Cape Santa Maria), decent beaches.

We fly from San Francisco, usually the red-eye, and then on to the islands. So, it’s a bit of a trek, but we love it.

Thanks in advance for any suggestions (including that I’m crazy for asking)!

Dave