Be sure to reserve and order early and ask if you'll need to regroup into 2 smaller parties. Give the host restaurant some grace to make sure you have a good time.
Should be no reason to regroup into smaller parties. Everyone on Anegada is used to catering to charter boats with 8+ people.
My first choice is Potter's for traditional Anegada grilled lobster cooked old school over torchwood in a steel drum.
I also love all the food at Wonky Dog and it's my first choice for a higher end gourmet dining experience on Anegada. I consider it among the top 5 restaurants in the BVI.
Sid's at Pomato point is a new favorite since it open. I've never had lobster there but I'm sure TessyAnn does a nice job.
