Any of you TTOL-ers care to share some of your insights about St. John (summer months) with respect to favorite overnight stops and favorite onshore rest/bars/sites?

I overnight-ed in Mahoe Bay many years ago and it was very nice, especially when we learned about the dinghy beach/roadside drop-off area...for cab pick-up/drop-off.

We missed 'woody's' that trip, but plan to make it there if we ever go back.

Has anyone rented a car?