Great trip report! You will hold those memories with your kids forever.
Sounds like you missed Spring Bay? That's where the jumping rock for the kids is! safe and tons of fun. Next time!
Bummed you missed Coco Maya as it is fabulous.
Agree-Top of the Baths is pricey for what you get. Next time do Mad Dogs instead!

I just made a rum cake yesterday with the LAST of my Arundel rum. Hope you brought some home!