Today we're flying Cape Air, which has been reliable for us. We have never flown InterCaribbean. I see they have cancelled their 4 pm flight today. Silver has also worked well for us, although some of our neighbors have had trouble. If your party is large enough, chartering a plane from SJU or STT makes sense.

Ratman has been doing this for over fifty years - before the airstrip was paved. It's now nearly thirty for me, so we've tried most options. Of course with a house, two boats and an old car, we're dragging more stuff than most!