Hi Everyone,

I'm planning a 40th Birthday trip for my wife. We'd like to go to the Caribbean and would be traveling from Philadelphia. We'll probably have a total of 4-6 people. I'm looking for island and sleeping suggestions that are nice, safe, and won't break the bank. Also looking for islands with direct flights from Philly that aren't much longer than 4.5 hours. I know, so many requirements.... ;-)

Any suggestions are greatly appreciated.

We were in Aruba last month, and have traveled to Bermuda, Turks, Tortola, and Jost Van Dyke.

Thanks!