JMHO...To me the water is about the same but Palm Beach is where all the high rises are and must admit that is where we have stayed 2 out of three times. I prefer it as you can walk to more things such as restaurants, shopping, bars. But Eagle is nice. Haven't stayed there only beached it. We stayed first time at Divi in low rise area. Nice but not close to anything at that time. More happening up in high rise area. What properties are you looking at?