Nutmeg, you and I do not seem to be on the same page with this.  It would be helpful if the board would allow simultaneous postings in both BVI and USVI boards.  I know there are a lot of people on the BVI board (myself included) who do not regularly check the USVI board.  I am trying to reach the broadest  audience of people who have done this trip via charter boat.  I understand there is a guided tour.   That is not what we are interested in.  I am specifically looking for information on the best water approach and the hike up from the beach. 
For those of you who have shared info about doing this  I appreciate it, especially those who gave info on the water approach.  
BEERMAN: your pictures are beautiful as always..  DIF setting in