Yes, we have kept our boat in Nanny Cay, VGHY, and Compass Pt. When we were at Compass Pt, my son lived aboard and paid the slip which is much more expensive then Nanny Cay or VGYH. No offense Jay, but we just do not like Independent Boatyard. Since Jay does his own work, no problem. We have had issues with outrageous quotes for repairs. We did not want to leave the boat in the water after Greg moved off island. We were not happy with the dry dock options or rules at Independent. To recap, VGYH is the least expensive, but difficult to get to and repair options or limited. We loved Nanny Cay for so many reasons. Restaurants, chandlery, provisions, pool, hotel if needed, and generally the people are very friendly. PM with any other questions