We're headed down in January and chartering with CYOA out of St. Thomas. As always, we will make St. John a priority. Although it gets awfully rolly with the ferry traffic, Caneel Bay is (in addition to the fabulous anchorages already mentioned) a beautiful stop. The resort there makes for a terrific stroll...some nice little shops and some really cool plantation ruins. But our real cant-miss is definitely Leinster. Beautiful, quiet anchorage with terrific snorkeling. Also, a dinghy ride to shore and a short hike take you to the preserved remains of Anaberg. Super cool.