We like Scrub for what it is - a resort with a two level infinity pool, hot tub, a fun little slide going into one of the pools, a couple good restaurants, and options for pampering typically found at high end resorts. It's a good place for the kids to (respectfully) let loose a bit while we get some relaxation time sitting by the pool and not worrying about the boat. Although we do go to the BVIs primarily for the sailing, beach bars and local culture, we do find Scrub a nice mid-way stop to mix things up a bit. BUT, we also like Marina Cay and I'm not saying you should necessarily choose Scrub over Marina Cay. Just depends on what you like and are after.

Matt