If you're determined that Talk of the Town is where you want to go, you'll have good food - ask for Ann is still working there. There are other good lolos that we find are better in quality than Talk of the Town. Our favorite is Scooby's with far superior lobster and a more eclectic menu (at least as far as menus at LoLos can go).

Regardless of which one you pick, you'll have a very enjoyable experience and it won't break the bank! As the previous poster mentioned, you can certainly get out of there for $20-$30 per person. (The first time we vacationed in Grand Case, we were walking down the street looking at the menus of all of the OTHER restaurants and I almost cried thinking that we would go hungry because the prices were so high but we blended in a few visits to the LoLos and were able to keep on budget )