Stayed at Lamberts and Tamarind in the last two times we were down there chartering. Lamberts hands down. Go for the garden room. #23 or 25. The rooms are simple. But best of all those rooms are 15 yards from the beach. North swell was up and heard surf all night long.
Geeta runs the desk, it will be slow season and she will bend over backwards to get you the room you want.