From what I hear and have read, Officer Benjamin was a fine man and what happened to him is absolutely inexcusable and cannot be excused in any way or to any degree. I do not think Bibi was making excuses for the inexcusable - I think she was simply telling the story about the criminals to help explain the horrible problem that exists on the island with too many young men with nothing to do but seek and find trouble. I know that Bibi can be controversial with many, but I do not think the comments about her story are fair.