Nobbie,

Some of the posters may have missed that your flight is originating in the UK and, therefore, may not be connecting in San Juan. If that's the case, of course, consider dining at your Caribbean gateway wherever that is, if the timing is appropriate. As has been indicated, options on Tortola will be limited after your arrival time.

The Tamarind Club is convenient to Hodges Creek, but typically ends food service at 2200. You may want to contact them to see if they might have some flexibility for your party.

Welcome to TTOL!