$199/day was definitely NOT correct.

Service does vary depending who answers when you call. Can be a touch variable I suppose.

The problem with Jerry and Denzil is that it's my understanding that they don't do short term rentals anymore.

I made my reservations over the phone direct with the local office. I also call the day before and labor the point a bit about exactly what my plans are, what time I want to be picked up and where, etc. It's seemed to work out fairly well, by island standards. That's my recommendation in any case, and that applies to just about any arrangements. Call ahead and communicate to confirm your plans and remind them you're coming and things tend to work out more smoothly.