Well we will definitely try it in January and see what we think. I like having restaurants around Oyster Pond for those nights when we don't want to drive too far so having another new place to try is great. I use Trip Advisor a lot and do a lot of reviews myself on hotels and restaurants on there. I agree I've been disappointed with some places I thought would be great based on the reviews but it is just another tool when traveling to a new place to get ideas on where we want to stay or dine just like we use Travel Talk for places to try on the island. Everyone has different tastes and opinions on what they like. But it is fun for us to try new places we read about and make our opinion on what we think