To add more opinions ... we usually have a mid-morning snorkel at Loblolly and lunch there with lunch drinks from The Big Bamboo. Then head to points west in a counter-clockwise circle around the island. Please don't be tempted to take your rental along the "dotted line" road between Loblolly and Windlass Bight. It just gets worse, and worse, and worse and eventually you have to turn around after having committed a good half hour to the road. Much better to go back down to the airstrip and then hang a right.