You need to be more careful with how you use this forum. You use "them" in a way that appears to finger TMM, when I believe your target is CatCo. How can anyone trust the accuracy of your review, when you accidentally (I assume) point at TMM (with whom I have had many great charters)?
I would like to recommend BVI Yacht Charters - wonderful boats, fantastic service - we have 8 charters with them so far with zero disappointments - all boats in fantastic shape, great customer service. Bonus is they are directly across the street from the big Riteway so provisioning is easy peezy breezy.
Recently finished 12 days aboard a Lagoon 52. Great boat in excellent shape. Wonderful service at their base. One minor problem and the chase boat was to us in 45 minutes. Be advised that their start time is 5 PM however use your TTOL membership discount. With the large number of additional charters going out of Hodges Creek it has become rather crowded with delays at the fuel dock,just factor in some extra time. We will definitely use them again. We now have over 22 charters under our belt so do have a little experience with many companies