Amalie Car Rental - like Paradise they also meet you curbside at STT, arrival and departure, with a gorgeous jeep. They did marina drop and pick-up for us as well last month. If you want a car for next month book it NOW. St. Thomas is very busy - seems everyone is traveling there now due to travel restrictions elsewhere - there have been many reports of individuals not being able to secure vehicle reservations. We book at least 6 months in advance when traveling to STT/STJ.
Second Paradise. They were fantastic. We used them for arrival and departure, six adults in the last two weeks.
we dropped off at Compass Point after using for airport transfers, grocery runs, and dinner round-trip. And they left us a vehicle prior to our return this past Sunday! We went to lunch following checkout, and then took skyline Road, the scenic way back to the airport. Gorgeous views from up high where we had cruised at sea level.