what pizza place is recommended in the simpson bay area..........we got some in 2019, but cant remember the name........thanks in advance..............

We like the pizza at Juliette's, in Pelican Key.

Isola had great pizza but no clue if the quality is the same after the recent change

Exactly. We used to go there for pizza on a night when we didn't want to drive, but with the changes there, I'd recommend Juliette's, as it's a known.

Pizza Italy at SBYC is quite good and we enjoy the pizza there. Also, I wouldn't discount Isola, the head chef(Matteo) is still there and his kitchen always put out excellent food.

Pizza Italy and Pizza Del Sol are both good options.

Buccaneer Beach Bar has excellent pizza.

thanks everyone......our very favorite place in maho on the back alley isnt there since the last hurricane..................

We used to love Pizza Pasta, it was our go to dinner spot, upon arrival on the island, and Selena was an absolute gem!

bdeeley--that's interesting, as others have said the chef has changed at Isola.

We like Pizza Italy, Juliette's

Not a fan of Buccaneer Beach Bar pizza. Last one we had was burned and was like eating cardboard, way too thin crust.

Why is that funny? The long time head chef, is and has been Matteo Bottini, and I spoke with him yesterday and he is still there. As was mentioned on another thread, supposedly a long time cook has left Isola.

Not in Simpson Bay, but probably the best pizza now is at Fat Tony's in Jordan Village.

Funny? I didn't say it was funny. I said that others have said that the chef had changed. Is the chef still the same or not??

Pizza past was also one of our go to places with pizza appetizer and eggplant over chicken parmigiana.
Bob

Pizza Pasta is one of the places i miss most about the old days. To this day, i still swear and talk about my fave dish there, their lasagna. Was my all time favorite place to get lasagna anywhere. LOVED it...and do miss the place, and also miss seeing Selena, ilda and dario. Those were the good old days!

Pizza Pasta was a favorite of ours too back in the day. Lack of air conditioning was a negative but food made up for it.

Is Mama pizza still at Porto Cupecoy?

Pizza Italy has great dough, homemade gelato and I'd go there just for the excellent friendly service we received.
Although we denied the "bread" course, so glad the server insisted as it is made with the pizza dough

Not fancy but reasonably priced

Yes Mama Pizza is still there in Cupecoy. We enjoyed our pizza there. And they do deliver.

I agree, the pizza there is fantastic!

Mamma Pizza, as well as Pizza & Co.

But, we also plan ahead and bring one home with us from Orange Fever. That and a homemade salad, and dinner is done.