When booking with American, there's an option to land in MIA at 0920 with a flight to Beef Island at 1040. Is that sufficient time? Does AA have a good track record there?

Ms RW? You're the only person I know that's taken the flight more than once. Any insight?

Or book the the 1205 in an abundance of caution?

BTW, RT from Memphis, 10/31-11/8 is 34.5k miles. A decent value on flight miles.

We've done it, as have our friends from New Albany who also own a BVI house. You could check the on-time performance of the Memphis-Miami flight, but I'm guessing it's pretty good as the plane arrives in Memphis the night prior.

That should be plenty of time. Your flight from Memphis would be originating and those tend to be reliable.
G

Thanks, both of you! I didn't even consider that it was originating from Memphis-that should cut down on potential issues.

Do check the night before that your flight is posted ontime in the morning. If not it gives you time to work on other arrangements.