TravelTalkOnline Forums Travel and Vacation Forums British Virgin Islands Dinner (i.e. not lunch) recommendations on Anegada?

Who's doing it best this spring? Wonky Dog, Lobster Trap, Reef Hotel, Sid's? It's been year or so since I've been, things change, want to give my crew (including my grand-kids!) a great experience. (Sorry to ask a frequently recurring question, but a search doesn't reveal any recent answers re/ a dinner recommendation on Anegada.)

We love Lobster Trap! My favorite dish is the Lobster Thermador. My wife loves their Cracked Conch. That being said, we have also enjoyed Anegada Reef Hotel for the beautiful setting along the water and great grilled Lobster. Potters is a fun party atmosphere and Sids is always very good. We've tried Wonky Dog. Nothing bad to say. I hear their lamb shank is the best, but I haven't tried it yet. My favorite lamb shank was Upstairs at Leverick. Unbelievable!

IMHO hands down Wonky Dog though you really can't go wrong with the others.

Lamb shank at Wonky Dog is amazing and love Lobster Trap and Sid's.those would be my choices..

We like the Anegada Beach Club for the ambience (and when we went a couple of years ago the food was good also).

Sids is a hidden gem. Reservations a must, you won’t be disappointed.

Wonky Dog has the best food hands down, but I agree that the other restaurants have really stepped up their game. Can't really go wrong!

I can recommend Sids and ABC .

Sid’s is a great place