We are staying at the Royal Palm and looking for a decent New York style pizza place for an easy dinner tonight. Anything worthwhile in Simpson Bay Area? Thx all.

Pizza Galley - across the street

Thanks!

That's not NY style pizza though.

Not sure exactly what NY style is, but very accustomed to New Haven style and it fit the bill. It's definitely not deep dish

NY style is thin pizza.

That's what I thought, it's not paper thin, but was close enough considering your not in NY but St. Maarten. Try get a table on the water.

Perfect!

Try BBB on Billy Folly road right on Simson bay
<img src="http://www.traveltalkonline.com/forums/images/graemlins/Groovin.gif" alt="" />

Pizza Italy hands down the best we have had since Italy. Remember NY got their pizza from Italy and they have thin, soft, foldable dough.Real Mozz, no fake blends as are very common these days.

Where is it?

next to the marina

We stayed at the Flamingo in October and had great pizza at BBB, Pizza del Sol and Pizza Gallery. All were good with a great selection of toppings.

Had good thin pizza at Pizza Galley just now. It did the trick!

Pizza Galley is good, it is NOT NY style pizza. NY pizza is not describable nor able to be reproduced.

True JD. Just because we are in the islands, I wasn't about to settle for Dominos or Pizza Hut---never do that in the states either. Just happy that the sauce wasn't ketchup being called marinara! LOL. Pizza Galley was not NY but it was acceptable for our quest for an easy meal across the street. Thx all.

How's the headache?

It's better, thanks, but neck and traps are extremely tight. Too sore to massage.

There's a pizza place just over the drawbridge and past Mc Donalds called the Pizza Company. They serve what I think is NY style. It's hand tossed. Remember it as being too big for the box.

Cugini makes pretty good pizza

I love Pizza and Co.