crmoores,

So true on your Water Island caveat. St Thomas is a wonderful island with lots of things to do and see, but a visitor must be aware of the cruise ship schedule to enjoy all it can offer. Since the giant ships have been coming in numbers and now with two deep ports, the island's infrastructure is being stretched - IMHO.

Point of clarification if earlier post was confusing. The Honeymoon Beach I was speaking of is on St John. Albeit it is a popular snorkel spot for many of the day sails out of Red Hook.