I've wanted to try the chicken and potatoes on our last two trips but it never worked out because we ate on the beach for our lunches at LaPlaya or the year prior had other lunch plans. We typically don't return immediately to our resort so couldn't keep it in the car.

The rotisserie is closest to Macaron where I've purchased items several times over the course of a few days and witness people randomly purchasing the chicken and potatoes. I asked the server about it myself and wasn't told I had to have pre ordered. Must be in high demand now?