We stayed at Scrub precharter and pre Irma. Tip: you can (when we stayed) get delicious hot breakfast sandwiches from the deli for a fraction of the price of breakfast in tne restaurants. Eat them poolside :-)
I’d just arrange for a cab on Anegada. The car is nice if you have a group or will be there a full day/night but for limited time I think prearranged cab is better. I wholeheartedly recommend drinks at Cow Wreck and the wonky Dog for lobster dinner - what chef peter is cooking up in terms of the lobsters and the sides is amazing. You won’t be disappointed. We’re headed to Anegada for a week late Feb and can’t wait!