All three are good choices and nice properties, but it is a bit like I need to buy a car what should I buy. Unless we know what you are looking for the ability to direct in the best way possible is impossible. Stayed at all three, liked all three for different reasons and would not hesitate to stay at any of the three other than OBBR as we prefer the Simpson Bay / Maho areas and probably the biggest item for us is that it is closer to where the people we tend to hang out with live closer to.
Cheers,
T