Topper's had/has a very good burger, but beyond that it was only so-so. Agree with Scubaman's assessment. Many people who visit St. Maarten tend to return to the same places they have visited in the past, and never take the time to explore the entire island and all the great dining spots that exist on both sides of the island. So, sometimes people overhype certain places without realizing that there may be better options elsewhere.