We also randomly went to the Windmill Bar when we were there in May and LOVED it. We had been hanging out at Maho Crossroads (I know, Beerman, not your favorite place but I'm a Deadhead, so I like the vibe.) and John, the owner, and his friend, Spoons talked us into going that afternoon to see live music. So...we carted 6 recent college graduates up the hill to the Windmill Bar and had the best time and the BEST chicken rotis. The shortage of Presidente was evident in May and June when we were there. Something about the bottle supplier being behind so they didn't have a way to bottle it???