I hate to admit this but we have only been to Sal e Pepe once and that was in the original location and at the suggestion of Lesley Bruce. We had a lovely dinner, well prepared and well served.

I’ve wanted to try the new location since the setting appears to be lovely but the mixed opinions have scared me off from doing so with all the other great island restaurants. We’ll have to give it another try next trip and form our opinion on our own first hand experience since in the end, everyone’s experience ergo opinions can differ.