RatmansWife had it correct: "If you have five people, Cape Air coupons are likely to save you money to Beef. Nervous flyers may want to avoid VG." A Cape Air "Travel Pass" is good for 10 segments and costs $2,500 and as per the company's website: "Please note: TravelPass accounts may have up to 5 travelers on a group account," and thus all five of you can get over here and back to SJU for $250 for each flight. https://www.capeair.com/travelpass/index.html