Our experiences with SJ have been hit and miss over the years. We swore off the place after a group of us went with a reservation and service was less than stellar, waiter was snarky and lots of mishaps with our food. Having said that we went back this past trip and the Grouper was very good, no problems with service. It's a lovely location overlooking the lagoon and when they have a good price for the lobster they get added to our list of must do.