DYC has been a hot mess both in the USVI and BVI. Don’t know if things have improved. Virgin Island Yacht Charters was in Compass Point. I absolutely can not recommend them. Send me a PM if you want info.

Really surprised about CYOA. Jay runs a great shop and this is not a typical experience.

If you do end up doing USVI to BVI make sure the boat you charter has all permits and paperwork in place to enter BVI. Not all do. I’d charter from the BVI.