Thank you very much for your input Carol I'm reassured that I'm not completely off my rocker trying to pull this off! LOL!

We have been to St Maarten/St Martin before so the goal was to try to maximize time on Anguilla. I haven't yet found any direct flight from EIS to AXA (Anguilla) but I'm praying to the travel gods that maybe, just maybe one of the small airlines will add the route. It sure would make things easier!

And thanks for the advice to post on the SXM forum. I'll do that shortly.