I understand the negative commentary, but for us Willy T was open during Covid when almost nothing else was, and when the owner catches Wahoo it's the best cut of fish we've had in the BVI.
second this!!! Ewan the owner LOVES fishing, and when he catches fresh wahoo or tuna he brings it directly back to the Willie T and serves it there.
Hard to find a better or fresher fish anywhere in the BVI imo.