Thank you so much for the well-wishes everyone!

lcote - thank you for the recommendation @ Moulin Fou - we are most definitely wine drinkers!

extreme and Gakaye - Le Cottage and L'Estaminet were two on my list for some time - I think I might have to do two French dinners in Grand Case! I get a little on edge about parking in Grade Case in the past - are they close to the two parking lots on the main drag?

RoryS - congratulations on so many anniversaries in SXM! We are just getting started :-) I am not familiar with Charter House or the former Saratoga location but looks like its walking distance which is always a plus.