I am also interested in what people suggest for our family of six consisting of 3 boys (11,10,7) and 1 girl (5). We will be on a marinemax 443 for an 8 day charter. Boys are pushing for fishing gear just not sure it's practical or fruitful based on research. I'm thinking a 3 man kayak for boys to cruise around a SUP with a few floats and noodles. Also considering upgrading to a nice 17' dingy with a 90 to give us ability to venture out and explore multiple areas from one anchorage. Anyone ever upgraded dingy that can say whether it's worth extra money? Also considered packing some inflateables to save some money.