We like Over the Rainbow, but I checked your dates and it is booked already. Bummer! The Reef Bay and Fish Bay areas are nice to be able to get back into town easily. We have also stayed at Gallows Point which is wonderful if you want to be able to walk to dinner and the happy hours. If you wanted to stay at the opposite end of St John. We love Villa Gin De Mer. Amazing privacy and views, views, views.