We've only flown into EIS. This works out best for us for a few reasons: price, coach is only about $100 cheaper to go through STT, first is normally almost the same EIS vs STT. Second we have been doing land based after our last 2 charters on VG or Anegada, so EIS is very handy when we return. Granted when we land at EIS and have to cab all the way to West End we have a $70 cab fare, but you would have cab and ferry expenses if you go into STT. In my opinion I would use whichever fits your schedule & budget the best. No need for a porter at EIS either!