Tintamarre isn't much in the line of exploring but it's close, inexpensive to get there, and if you want a peaceful retreat it's okay. Be prepared for no services if you opt for Tintamarre......

Of all the near islands, my personal preference is Saba because it is so very different from all the others but since it's not even on your list and there aren't any beaches to speak of..........

St. Bart's is beautiful if you want to go where the beautiful people go and do what the beautiful people do and you can afford to spend like they spend. Today, having tried about every means of getting there, I would fly over from Esperance Airport and if there is such a thing anymore, I'd try for a catamaran sail back, or else one of the fast ferry boats. Beaches are gorgeous and it is very beautiful. Rent a car and explore and check out the famous beaches where the rich and famous play. Passports required along with a thick wallet.......

My preference is Anguilla because it's all StB isn't. Well, except for expensive which it can be or not, depending on how you choose to spend a day there. The beaches are drop dead gorgeous and there are many beaching and dining options but the island itself is flat (Anguilla=eel) and not terribly picturesque where StB is hilly and very scenic with some equally incredible beaches. Anguilla has some excellent snorkeling spots and the people are very friendly. <img src="http://www.traveltalkonline.com/forums/images/graemlins/handshake.gif" alt="" /> <img src="http://www.traveltalkonline.com/forums/images/graemlins/handshake.gif" alt="" />