Years ago at C&F, when the grocery shelves in the back were stocked pretty well, 4 of us had a great dinner. They had an almost new bottle of Frangelico out on the counter. We each ordered a glass. When we were ready to leave, we asked if they had a full bottle they could sell us to take back to the boat. Mrs. F (embarrasses me that I don't recall her name) said she would check. She didn't have another, but said she would sell us the open bottle for something like $4. We loved that island spirit and kindness. We took the partial bottle, I think we insisted on $15, and had a wonderful memory!
And just have never found another place quite like Pirates / Saba.... You just never knew who or what you might see there, the beer was cold and the burgers first rate! ( Beer was probably warm and the burgers just ok, but the atmosphere, location, and characters just made everything better!)