I miss Craig and Sally's in Frenchtown, St. Thomas.
The new place there (Twisted Cork) is good, but not the same.

Also miss the Jolly Roger/Soapers. Many years ago the wife and I were having dinner and a few policemen sauntered in and arrested somebody. It was all so low key and "proper" you just had to laugh. Very British. Little fuss.

Pusser's in Soapers used to have a Piranha Bar. I miss that too. Those little guys would stare at your toes while you drank at the bar. Gave my girlfriend (now wife) the willies. If you got there at the right time you could watch them get fed... a couple of pieces of raw chicken.