YOu wrote
".... we thought we would spend more time on Orient exploring, ..."

I think that is the right attitude, explore
How about 1 - 2 days of a mini beach bar crawl!! to get to know the various places - check out menu's, signature drinks and the vibe for each spot. Chat with the staff, you'll soon figure out your fav's. What we like may not be what you like - this yr we had fun at Good Time Charlies when Johnny Carib played for a bit late in the afternoon, tried out the Mojito Guy - that's the fun of a beach exploration.
Let us know what you find and like

J&B