Traveltalkonline.com Forums


BVI Cruise Schedule TTOL Sponsors BVI Travel Calendar
Forum Statistics
Forums39
Topics38,429
Posts310,033
Members26,538
Most Online2,218
Jan 21st, 2020
Top Posters(30 Days)
RonDon 115
pat 43
jazzgal 41
Todd 40
Member Spotlight
Aries4
Aries4
Morrisville, PA/West End, Tortola
Posts: 437
Joined: July 2006
Show All Member Profiles 
Today's Birthdays
ecco, OceanDrop, vincent
Who's Online Now
53 registered members (socamon, pandpfromcanada, SXMScubaman, Wahnfried, SeaLady29, CaribbeanCanadians, MrEZgoin, sailingbob, polaris, 706jim, KenW, marisol, Swifty, xrayman67, boucharda, Todd, deliveryskipper, Kevin_B, eilandmens, lcote, JandIrene, RichiT, Bernd, bobsob, luvtotravel, SXMNAN, StMartinFan, MKGrey, SirRichard, Fletch, nevar37, taraavo, OceanSong, pburke40, RickG, Scooter, duckfat, BillB42, 15 invisible), 991 guests, and 71 spiders.
Key: Admin, Global Mod, Mod
Previous Thread
Next Thread
Print Thread
Rate Thread
Plane crash from Beef Island #166222
07/20/2018 09:08 AM
07/20/2018 09:08 AM
Joined: Aug 2000
Posts: 82,469
Central Florida!
Carol_Hill Offline OP
Traveler
Carol_Hill  Offline OP
Traveler
Joined: Aug 2000
Posts: 82,469
Central Florida!
This story

was in the St. Maarten paper about the Beef Island crash. Perhaps it was an engine failure, as the plane was supposedly outbound when it crashed.


Carol Hill
BVI Sponsors
Re: Plane crash from Beef Island [Re: Carol_Hill] #166338
07/21/2018 08:06 PM
07/21/2018 08:06 PM
Joined: Apr 2004
Posts: 10,999
Macon, Georgia
GlennA Offline
Traveler
GlennA  Offline
Traveler
Joined: Apr 2004
Posts: 10,999
Macon, Georgia
It was a Cessna 150 two seat aircraft. Must have been an engine failure as a 150 can takeoff in less than 1/3 the length of the Beef Island runway.


Travel is fatal to prejudice, bigotry, and narrow-mindedness, and many of our people need it sorely on these accounts. - Mark Twain
Re: Plane crash from Beef Island [Re: Carol_Hill] #166343
07/21/2018 09:38 PM
07/21/2018 09:38 PM
Joined: May 2011
Posts: 1,212
JAX
jphart Offline
Traveler
jphart  Offline
Traveler
Joined: May 2011
Posts: 1,212
JAX
Hmmm....Late afternoon in a 150 for a ~220nm flight?
Some of you fly-boys tell us what’s wrong here?


JPH
I spent my money on booze, broads, and boats...the rest I wasted.
Re: Plane crash from Beef Island [Re: jphart] #166344
07/21/2018 09:56 PM
07/21/2018 09:56 PM
Joined: Oct 2013
Posts: 528
Ohio
jagmansr Offline
Traveler
jagmansr  Offline
Traveler
Joined: Oct 2013
Posts: 528
Ohio
I learned to fly in 150s,,, there are a lot of variables that could factor into the crash. Yes, engine problems, too much loaded weight, if there was a tail wind, how strong? My condolences to the pilot’s family. Too many possible reasons to assume why. Most crashes are simply a fluke considering how rare they are. 150’s are a simple and great aircraft to fly. There had to have been one or more unusual factors that caused the crash.

Re: Plane crash from Beef Island [Re: Carol_Hill] #166345
07/21/2018 10:01 PM
07/21/2018 10:01 PM
Joined: Apr 2002
Posts: 6,993
GA/NC
GeorgeC1 Offline
Traveler
GeorgeC1  Offline
Traveler
Joined: Apr 2002
Posts: 6,993
GA/NC
The odd thing is if the crash was a engine failure it should have been survivable. The 150 would be ditched at a very low airspeed. The pictures seemed to show a much higher speed impact.
G

Re: Plane crash from Beef Island [Re: Carol_Hill] #166347
07/21/2018 10:14 PM
07/21/2018 10:14 PM
Joined: Oct 2013
Posts: 528
Ohio
jagmansr Offline
Traveler
jagmansr  Offline
Traveler
Joined: Oct 2013
Posts: 528
Ohio
Regardless of the altitude the plane got to, pilot error could have also cause a stall resulting in the same situation of engine failure

Re: Plane crash from Beef Island [Re: jphart] #166353
07/22/2018 12:21 AM
07/22/2018 12:21 AM
Joined: Apr 2014
Posts: 304
Rockford, Michigan
aarpskier Offline
Traveler
aarpskier  Offline
Traveler
Joined: Apr 2014
Posts: 304
Rockford, Michigan
Originally Posted by jphart
Hmmm....Late afternoon in a 150 for a ~220nm flight?
Some of you fly-boys tell us what’s wrong here?


The following is based on published news reports and specs. A Cessna 150's gross weight is 1,600 lbs and empty weight is 970 lbs, so useful load is 630 lbs. The distance from Tortola to Guadaloupe is 170 nm (not 220 nm). Range with standard tanks, at 75% power cruise speed, is 300 nm. Fuel capacity without long range tanks is 26 gallons, or about 208 lbs, leaving 422 lbs for pilot (there was no passenger) and gear. Long range tanks would add 10 gallons, or another 80 lbs. If the pilot weighed 200 lbs, then 222 lbs was left for cargo with standard tanks and 142 lbs for cargo with long range tanks. Temperature was 88 F and humidity was 60%. Weight and balance, and density altitude, would not seem to be causative factors.

Some news reports state that there was a "runway overrun." Take off distance for a Cessna 150 at gross weight over a 50 ft obstacle is 1,375 ft. The EIS runway is 4,642 ft. Runway length would not seem to be a causative factor.

Pictures of the damage suggest a stall, i.e. failure to maintain lift, which leaves (1) engine failure, and/or (2) pilot error.

Re: Plane crash from Beef Island [Re: Carol_Hill] #166468
07/23/2018 09:31 PM
07/23/2018 09:31 PM
Joined: Jan 2016
Posts: 933
Georgia & South Carolina
D
Deepcut Offline
Traveler
Deepcut  Offline
Traveler
D
Joined: Jan 2016
Posts: 933
Georgia & South Carolina
I heard of this as I pulled into Leverick bay on the day of accident. (I am a pilot). Regarding time of departure, there was plenty of time to make trip and arrive before dark. Distance not factor. Runway length certainly not issue. Winds were generally as expected that day. Often C150 is used as trainer plane or "building time". Most likely cause is pilot error (Distracted by something inside or outside of plane). Potentially banking too much at too low of altitude and causing stall. Could be easy to do looking down/back as plane turning just after takeoff.

Just my opinion. RIP


Wes
s/v Sea Tiger (2022 Lagoon 46)
www.BareBoatBVI.com

Re: Plane crash from Beef Island [Re: Deepcut] #166483
07/24/2018 08:22 AM
07/24/2018 08:22 AM
Joined: Jul 2008
Posts: 3,003
S
sail445 Offline
Traveler
sail445  Offline
Traveler
S
Joined: Jul 2008
Posts: 3,003
There have been a few cases at SJU where unscrupulous gas dealers would sell fuel not meeting the specs and the planes revved up and conked out on the runway.

Re: Plane crash from Beef Island [Re: Carol_Hill] #166495
07/24/2018 10:21 AM
07/24/2018 10:21 AM
Joined: Apr 2002
Posts: 6,993
GA/NC
GeorgeC1 Offline
Traveler
GeorgeC1  Offline
Traveler
Joined: Apr 2002
Posts: 6,993
GA/NC
It was not a simple engine failure followed by a ditching. Either the aircraft stalled or control was not maintained and the aircraft impacted the water at high speed. Generally in a accident like this there is a distraction that causes the loss of control. Could be a engine failure, rough running engine, cargo shift, instrument failure ect.. The Golden rule of flying is prioritize aviating, navigating and communicating in that order. The next rule is if a accident is not avoidable fly the aircraft all the way to the crash. You might walk away however if you stall or lose control the outcome is never pretty.
Someone mentioned fuel. One of the big issues in the Caribbean is water getting into the fuel. A slug of water will stop the engine. Water can get in the tanks through condensation, bad fuel caps or poor practices by the fueler. Aircraft tanks are supposed to be sumped for water before flight but crashes caused by water occur often.


Powered by UBB.threads™ PHP Forum Software 7.6.1