My sister is heading to SXM in April and she’s thinking about either Pinel or Anguilla for a day trip. I’m a little biased on my choice, so I thought I’d ask here what everyone thought and why they would choose one over the other. TIA

We have been to Pinel many times. Dry pretty and relaxing with beautiful views and very good food. We never went to Anguilla because of the Timon a boat and in a cab. I have read Kant reports on how nice Anguilla is, but just don’t want to spend too much time getting to destinations.

I have sent more days at pinel and only 3 times at Anguilla the both are different. I enjoy both Anguilla is a large island with a number of great beach’s but will cost more with the ferry car rental or taxi. While I enjoy pinel if I only had to choose one and cost isn’t a concern I would pick Anguilla.