We will be spending a night pre charter at the Nanny Cay hotel in late June. I need to figure out which restaurant is better for a casual good meal because I will need to make reservations for our party of 9. Do either restaurants have live music on Friday nights? Or one has better food?

Thank you for your help

You could also choose Gene's, which is just around the corner in Sea Cow Bay (a short taxi ride or dinghy ride in good settled weather). I like Peg Legs but the food is better at Omar's and Gene's. There also an option for food and drink at Captain Mulligan's which is at the entrance to Nanny Cay.

Gene's husband, Robin, provides a free shuttle, and you always get their warm hospitality. Manuel Reef still has a lot of sunken boats, so other restaurants may have a better view.